We would not know who to trust and what to expect from others. Therefore, before considering how to apply moral frameworks to contemporary problems, we must offer some reasons for using moral frameworks to address these issues instead of non-moral ones.
Everyone seeks what is most serviceable to himself.
The pivotal consideration, according to Taylor, regards how an individual wishes to define her identity. The pivotal consideration, according to Taylor, regards how an individual wishes to define her identity. For example, the Old Testament book of Leviticus contains a myriad of laws e.
In some cases, early passages in certain texts prohibit a behavior that is later endorsed or vice-versa. PlatoRepublic a-b. In a certain way, this makes the title question meaningless, since to ask "Why do X? In the first framework, the sentence "There are situations in which one ought not be moral" is meaningless nonsense.
Plato's variation of this argument: Why should I be moral? In this scenario, the risk is minimal, and the payoff is very high. There is a genuine failure in both approaches to make morality the ultimate value and to internalize the moral rules that they claim we ought to follow.
The Bible is inconsistent on the matter. Another inconsistency has to do with whether or not the OT rules have been superseded. Proposed justifications are found throughout the history of moral philosophy, but these reasons to be moral remain controversial.
When Jesus forbade divorce and remarriage Matt. But even apart from that, the usual answer "because it can get you into heaven" is itself fraught with difficulties. But I think that it is possible to have a different conceptual framework and to view morality differently.
Anyway, our current conceptions of morality have very little to do with what is written in the Bible.
Nontheists could reply in this way just as well as theists. We get a satisfaction out of helping others. Many believe that ethical considerations are simply omitted from this framework and that financial institutions operate using non-moral principles. On this view, telling the truth is considered morally good if God commands it, but telling lies is also considered morally good if God commands it.
Being moral leads to happiness and self satisfaction. There are newspapers that have regular features with questions and answers concerning these matters. Thus, there is a question that is prior to "Why be moral?
So D1 and the "expediency approach" must remain as a possible answer to our title question, though it will probably be unsatisfactory to many philosophers and people in general. If D1 is used, then the title question may be reformulated as "Why follow moral rules imposed by others?If you're asking why we should want to be moral, it's because morality is in our self interest by definition.
If you accept the idea that morality (or moral action) is "The way we ought to act" "ought" implies that we have an obligation to act in that way. Why Should I Be Moral? The question of morality proves to be a complex interrogatory.
Should I be moral? If I should be, then why? Why is morality important to society? An assumption can be made that morals derive from a purely religious perspective or the Golden Rule approach.
We. •“Why should we be moral when it is our self-interest to be immoral?” (Plato, 53) •Egoism is a challenge to morality •Two forms: Egoism Proper &.
Jun 03, · The philosopher Peter Singer discusses morality and enlightened self-interest. Question: Why should we behave morally? Peter Singer: I mean, the sound bite answer is. Justifying why one should behave morally is a surprisingly difficult task.
Proposed justifications are found throughout the history of moral philosophy, but these reasons to be moral remain controversial. In ‘Why should I be moral?’ the ‘Why should I?’ was another way of saying, What good is virtue?
or rather, For what is it good? and we saw that in asking, Is virtue good as a means, and how so?
we do assume that virtue is not good, except as a means. The dogma at the root of the question is hence clearly.Download